I love sharing articles that make people think. I always enjoy seeing how different people read the same text and get completely different ideas and opinions from them. It's not about right & wrong - but it does prove to me that it's best to read things several times - particularly longer items.
It's easy to fix on 1 or 2 parts of a text and miss other ideas. Of course - what's important to 1 person is irrelevant to another - and that plays a role also.
After yesterday's post about the music biz I got a few e-mails, myspace messages and phone calls from peeps all with different takes and ideas about what Seth's article says and what it means.
Like all of you - I also have my own ideas about what the article says and means. Mind if I share?
For the indie artist (like me, and many of you) - there's 1 crucial point made in the article which simply cannot be ignored. It's the one point that's as old school as the music itself - but we seem to overlook or forget it in many of these discussions.
Many musicians have understood that all they need to make a (very good) living is to have 10,000 fans. 10,000 people who look forward to the next record, who are willing to trek out to the next concert. Add 7 fans a day and you're done in 5 years. Set for life. A life making music for your fans, not finding fans for your music.
That is the insulation - the innoculation - the insurance policy against whatever "distribution" methods rise and fall away.
Tapes, CDs, LPs, MP3s, P2P all come and go - what remains through it all is your fans. If they are true fans.
Obviously this part of the issue has NOTHING to do with free downloads and piracy and digital distribution and ubiquity and blah blah blah. Those are the discussions for techies trying to sell technology (not music) and for corporate interests trying to maintain control and huge profit margins in a universe changing too rapidly for them.
They are discussions that are important to musicians and artists, and we need to stay engaged and in touch with them.
But unless your bound up in bed with corporate interests - they are also a distraction if you don't have your 10,000 fans.
Here's the deal. CD's are dying. People aren't buying music anymore . . . . Who cares. You have 10,000 people who have given you permission to contact them DIRECTLY about how to download your new song - get a discount on your upcoming show and get the first listen to your new EP or have the chance to personalize something with your music etc....
It's about having fans. And rewarding them. Making them feel special - like they are a part of YOUR club - not just a generic consumer.
The reason people are having a problem figuring out what to do next in the music sales biz is because many of them are putting the cart before the horse. They're trying to sell music without fans. That's some hard shit to do.
If I were to take my music off the "hobby" shelf and "go pro" tomorrow - here's what I'd do. My number 1 goal would be to earn 10,000 fans.
How? Lots of ways - especially with the internet - but let's be honest - old school playing live constantly is the main engine.
Fist and foremost - I'd commit to spending at least a year giging my ass off. I mean non-stop, not home for weeks at a time gigging my ass off.
That means taking every possible gig and chance to play in front of audiences I could get.
I'd also leverage the wonderful medium of interconnectivity that is the internet. This will help multiply the efforts made on the road - but again - rubber hits the road by playing live. Period.
The calculus I see a lot of cats using for most gigs is "how much can I make on door + cd sales".
That's fine - but it's extremely short sighted if you don't already have your 10,000 fans.
Because the goal isn't just to make cash off the door and cd sales and then move on to the next show.
The goal is to earn 10,000 fans.
10,000 people who have met me - shaken my hand and said "YES" I will let you contact me IN THE FUTURE about your music and related activities. 10,000 people for whom I have first name - last name - town of occupancy and a valid e-mail address. 10,000 people who are highly likely to buy my stuff. That means putting on one hell of a show every single time. Old school.
Also - don't take the 10,000 figure too literally. Maybe you only need 5000 or maybe you need 20,000. The point remains - all efforts should be focused on getting a solid reliable fan club that you can communicate with directly. In fact - I'd say that if you don't have permission to contact someone - they're aren't part of your 10,000.
Realize you'll probably end up like every other organization where 80% of your revenue comes from just 20% of your fans. Use that as the calculus to determine what your magic number is.
I can't tell YOU how to do this.
But it's pretty obvious to me, that being without it is not really a business. It's a hobby.
So it has to be a goal - a focus and effort has to be put behind it rather than haphazardly HOPING it happens while your busy doing other things. It also helps if your music doesn't suck - but that's another conversation.
Again - I'm only a hobbyist - but I've done enough shows to have made some observations and formed some opinions.
There's one thing I often see other "pro" musicians NOT doing. Mingle with the "audience".
Back-stage is death. Sure you get to socialize with other musicians and drink & eat etc... but the "relationships" you really need to be making are in FRONT of the stage. Those are people who have ALREADY proven a willingness to PAY for music. Don't ignore them. Save the whole "back stage" vibe for when you have TOO MANY fans to meet personally. Even then - you should make an attempt to meet and connect with them.
EXAMPLE.
When I was invited to play a Victor Wooten's Bass Nature Camp over the summer - I wanted to give each of the 60 students a copy of my CD. No . . . not sell it - I'm in the BUILDING phase - so I wanted to give it away.
Now - I could have - like others - simply put a pile of my CDs on a table, announced they were free and then gone back to HANG out with Chuck Rainey, Victor Wooten & Steve Bailey as students grabbed a copy in the hall.
Instead - I took my CDs - piled them up on a table along the LUNCH line, sat on the edge of the table and personally handed my CD to each of the 60 students as they walked through the lunch line. I got a chance to meet each of them, say hello, share a few words and when requested - signed copies of the CD.
The potential for connection and long term relationships with people is worth far more than a single CD sale. Particularly moving forward. If people are less likely to buy recorded music - the connection you have with audiences needs to be deeper than a single $10.00 CD sale.
Of course - if you already have your 10,000 fans - you don't need to give your stuff away. Or do you?
Topic for another time.